When people search for affordable homes in Lake City, MI, they usually start by sorting listings from lowest to highest price. That is a reasonable first step, but it can be misleading. A home with a lower price and a long list of needed repairs can end up costing more than a slightly higher-priced home that is ready to live in.
The better question is not “What is the cheapest house?” but “What will this home really cost me each month and over the next few years?” Here is how to compare.
Step 1: Define “Affordable” for Your Own Budget
Affordable means something different for every household. Before you look at listings, figure out the monthly payment you are comfortable with, not just the maximum a lender might approve.
- Talk to a lender early. A pre-approval shows you what you can borrow and what your payment might look like. Our article on how mortgage pre-approval helps you win a home explains the process.
- Set a comfortable payment, leaving room for savings, emergencies, and everyday life.
- Know your cash to close, including down payment, closing costs, and reserves.
- Look into programs you may qualify for. Some buyers in rural Northern Michigan qualify for USDA loans; you can check a property’s location on the USDA eligibility map and read our overview of USDA loans in Northern Michigan. First-time buyers may also want to review first-time homebuyer financing programs.
You can also run numbers with our mortgage calculator, then confirm them with your lender.
Step 2: Compare Price Against Repair Costs
A lower list price often reflects the condition of the home. That can be an opportunity, but only if you know what you are taking on.
For each home on your short list, ask:
- How old are the roof, furnace, water heater, and windows?
- Are there signs of moisture, such as stains, musty smells, or a damp basement or crawl space?
- Is the home on a well and septic system, and are there records for them?
- What would need to be done right away versus what could wait a few years?
Then get real numbers. Rough estimates from contractors and the findings from your home inspection help you compare a “cheaper” home that needs work with one that does not. Keep in mind that some loan types have condition requirements, so a home that needs major repairs may limit your financing options. Ask your lender before you write an offer.
Step 3: Look at the Costs That Come After Closing
Two homes with the same price can have very different monthly costs. Add these to your comparison:
- Property taxes. In Michigan, a home’s taxable value can “uncap” the year after it sells, so the seller’s current tax bill may not be what you pay. If the home will be your primary residence, you will also want to file for the Principal Residence Exemption. The Michigan Treasury property tax pages explain both.
- Homeowners insurance, which can vary with the home’s age, condition, heating type, and location.
- Utilities. Ask for recent bills. Heating costs in a Northern Michigan winter can vary a lot depending on insulation, windows, and fuel type, such as natural gas, propane, or electric.
- Association or road fees if the property is on a private road or in an association.
- Ongoing maintenance, which tends to be higher for older homes and larger lots.
Step 4: Compare Listings Fairly
If you are comparing homes you find online, make sure you are comparing like with like:
- Note the date you looked at each listing. Prices and status change, and online sites can lag behind.
- Compare similar property types, such as a home in town versus a home on acreage, a manufactured home versus a site-built home.
- Look at price per square foot carefully. It can be useful, but lot size, outbuildings, condition, and location all affect value.
- Verify the details. Square footage, lot size, and features in a listing should be confirmed through records and your own visit.
A Simple Total-Cost Worksheet
For each home you are seriously considering, fill in:
- Purchase price
- Estimated monthly mortgage payment (principal and interest)
- Estimated monthly taxes after the sale
- Estimated monthly insurance
- Estimated monthly utilities
- Immediate repairs needed (one-time)
- Repairs likely in the next 3 to 5 years
- Association or road fees
Add it up and compare. The home with the lowest total, or the one whose costs you are most comfortable with, is your most affordable option, even if it is not the lowest price on the list.
Getting Started
For a broader look at the area, visit our Lake City real estate guide, and use the Buyers Guide to plan each step of your purchase. It also helps to read about common mistakes when purchasing a house before you start touring.
Let’s Find a Home That Fits Your Budget
Have a few Lake City homes on your list and want help comparing them? Call Justin at 231.920.7579, email justin@justinlewisrealestate.com, or send a message to talk through your search.
Justin Lewis is a REALTOR® with Five Star Real Estate serving Lake City and surrounding Northern Michigan communities.
Get the Monday Market Update
A quick look at Northern Michigan home prices, inventory and rates, in your inbox every Monday.
